Muffy Aldrich | The Thing Before Preppy

Muffy Aldrich | The Thing Before Preppy

A Boat Shoe Comparison: Sperry Topsider Originals vs L.L. Bean Casco Bay Mocs

Is there a reason to buy L.L. Bean Boat Shoes over Sperry Topsiders?

Muffy Aldrich's avatar
Muffy Aldrich
Apr 26, 2026
∙ Paid
The new L.L. Bean Boat Moc for Women in Bone Nubuck

I live in boat shoes in the warmer weather. We all do. And we always have. They are, in many regards, a perfect shoe.

In the beginning it was always the (Paul) Sperry Topsider because pretty much that was all there was. And it was all we needed. As I have mentioned ad nauseum, the Topsider factory was about an hour’s drive from where we lived on the Connecticut shore growing up, and we made regular treks to buy for the whole family. That segued over time to buying them from local boat yard stores, or upscale island shops.

In my old Sperry Women’s Bluefish.

And over time as manufacturing shifted from the US to lower cost countries, other companies jumped in and made their own version, mostly produced overseas (such as Dubarry), while a couple (like Quoddy and Rancourt) were still made in Maine.

We have had a flotilla of boat shoes.
User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Muffy Aldrich.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Muffy Aldrich · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture